As an academic advisor, you will often be privy to sensitive situations. Do you think honesty is always the best policy?
"This is a tricky question. While I generally believe honesty is the best policy, sometimes full disclosure can damage a person's self-esteem. In those instances, honesty isn't always the best policy. Instead, I may have to withhold information to protect that person or work around the truth a bit."
"I feel that honesty is the best policy so long as the honest comment does not come with the intention of being hurtful. Honesty is the best policy because it builds trust and respect in relationships. When truthful with others, we show that we value their feelings and opinions. It also allows us to maintain our integrity and avoid the guilt and stress of lying. Honesty may not always be the easiest or most convenient option, but in the long run, it is always the most beneficial for everyone involved."
"Honesty is always the best policy. Often, it is just a matter of how you communicate and deliver your message, so managing this with each situation is critical to building honest and trustworthy relationships."
Interviewers tend to ask various questions during job interviews to better understand your values, work ethic, and personality. Sometimes, they ask difficult or sensitive questions to see how you handle challenging situations. Most candidates would respond that being truthful is generally the best policy. However, certain situations may be appropriate to withhold information or use tact to protect someone's feelings or privacy. Ultimately, it's essential to use good judgment and consider the context of the situation before deciding how to proceed.
Community answers are written by other candidates practicing this set. Reading how others frame the same question is one of the fastest ways to sharpen your own.
Anonymous Answer
Yes, I do think honesty is the best policy. Even though it may be difficult for someone to hear, it is always best to be honest. By being honest, you can be realistic about the situation and then discuss possible solutions.
Marcie's Feedback
Good answer! You are straightforward and confident in your belief that honesty is always the best policy. You're right that this way any assessments of the situation will be realistic. Are there any times as an academic advisor, however, when you might want to be tactful? In other words, be truthful but perhaps soften the truth so as not to hurt someone's feelings? Perhaps just think this through, but as long as you answer with confidence and support your assertion, the interviewer will be receptive to your opinion. Nice job!
