How to Answer: You are alone in an elevator with two nurses from another floor who are talking about a patient. How would you respond?
Advice and answer examples written specifically for a Situational Nursing job interview.
42. You are alone in an elevator with two nurses from another floor who are talking about a patient. How would you respond?
How to Answer
Interviewers ask situational questions to test interviewees' people skills and their capacity to communicate and find optimal solutions. The answer here doesn't have to be work specific, unless it is apparent as in this question, but it's always a good idea to incorporate appropriate work behaviors in, when possible.
Written by Dianne Barnard on March 9th, 2021
1st Answer Example
"My grandmother always taught me that when you are silent about questionable things, in a way you are agreeing with them, or people might think that you are. I feel strongly about protecting patient rights, and I would be very uncomfortable in that situation. I think that I would feel compelled to address it right on the spot and very pleasantly say that I don't feel comfortable with the conversation. If they were talking details and gossip, I would address it and definitely report it to supervisors. If it were a casual slip and vague in content, I would definitely report it to the supervisor if anyone else was on the elevator but if not, I would just address them directly."
Written by Dianne Barnard on March 9th, 2021
2nd Answer Example
"I encountered almost this same scenario, except it was two doctors that I recognized by sight but didn't know by name. I would handle this scenario in the same way I handled that situation. In that situation, I calmly said, 'Doctor, please don't discuss patient information in front of a person without a need to know this information.' The doctor nodded and said, 'Thank you,' and the conversation stopped. I think calmly and firmly reminding staff or physicians of a patient's right to privacy is the way to go, most of the time. If for some reason I saw a breach of confidentiality in front of a patient or visitor, I would report it to the unit manager in addition to my reminder to the staff."
Written by Kate Buckley on January 10th, 2023
About the Author
I began my career in emergency medical services (EMS) over 30 years ago, working as a Firefighter-Paramedic, EMS Captain, Mental Health Technician, ER Technician, EMT and Paramedic Adjunct Instructor, and EMS Educator. During my career, I had the privilege of serving on over one thousand interview panels to help various organizations choose the right candidate for the job.
I have created curricula and training materials to prepare candidates for interviews and held mock interview courses for all types of healthcare professionals. My interview experience includes hiring emergency medical technicians, paramedics, firefighters, nurses, medical assistants, home health aides, and physician assistants.
As a coach and contributor for MockQuestions, I am excited to help you navigate your upcoming nursing interview. While these situational questions assess your critical thinking and communication skills, interviewers also ask these questions to gain insight into your personality to determine if you will be a good fit with the company culture. Remember to be relaxed and be your authentic self. Best of luck in nailing your interview!
Learn more about Krista Wenz