How to Answer: How would you handle a patient that assumes a 'helpless' role, does not do what is necessary for their treatment, and asks you to do certain tasks that they could and should perform for themselves?
Advice and answer examples written specifically for a Situational Nursing job interview.
39. How would you handle a patient that assumes a 'helpless' role, does not do what is necessary for their treatment, and asks you to do certain tasks that they could and should perform for themselves?
How to Answer
A nurse cares about patients, so it's difficult sometimes to recognize when we over function for patients and do not encourage them to be their best. Doing too much for patients is as damaging as doing too little. Nurses need to learn the subtle dance between empathy and advocacy for patients helping themselves. You want to encourage without being demeaning or too harsh, but also push them to do what they can for themselves in every situation possible. A weight lifter doesn't bench press 200 pounds over night but adds weight little by little. Each time a patient swings his own leg out of the bed, or shuffles to the bathroom with the assist of two, wonderful things are building incrementally in his or her body. Sometimes, nurses do things for patients because they are busy and don't have time for the slower patient to do it. Occasionally, on a booming floor this may be necessary, but should be the exception, not the rule.
Written by Dianne Barnard on March 9th, 2021
1st Answer Example
"Sally, today is bath day and it's a great day to get up and stretch your legs today. No bed bath today. I'll help you up and you can dangle at the edge of the bed while I turn the shower on. It will do you good to get up, and I'll help you so you don't fall, but we are going to try to walk independently to the bathroom today. Does that sound good?"
Written by Dianne Barnard on March 9th, 2021
2nd Answer Example
"When I work with a patient who seems to be acting helpless, I try to use motivational interviewing techniques to help them find a reason for why they might want to participate in their treatment plan. So, we might talk about their trying to get back to their apartment or home, their desire to be able to sit up at their grandchild's wedding, or another goal they want to reach. Then I help them see how taking a walk in the hall or using their incentive spirometer will help them get stronger and more likely to achieve their goal."
Written by Kate Buckley on January 10th, 2023
About the Author
I began my career in emergency medical services (EMS) over 30 years ago, working as a Firefighter-Paramedic, EMS Captain, Mental Health Technician, ER Technician, EMT and Paramedic Adjunct Instructor, and EMS Educator. During my career, I had the privilege of serving on over one thousand interview panels to help various organizations choose the right candidate for the job.
I have created curricula and training materials to prepare candidates for interviews and held mock interview courses for all types of healthcare professionals. My interview experience includes hiring emergency medical technicians, paramedics, firefighters, nurses, medical assistants, home health aides, and physician assistants.
As a coach and contributor for MockQuestions, I am excited to help you navigate your upcoming nursing interview. While these situational questions assess your critical thinking and communication skills, interviewers also ask these questions to gain insight into your personality to determine if you will be a good fit with the company culture. Remember to be relaxed and be your authentic self. Best of luck in nailing your interview!
Learn more about Krista Wenz