How to Answer: Imagine that the author of an article did not like your edits, and argued with you. What would you do?
Advice and answer examples written specifically for an Editor job interview.
4. Imagine that the author of an article did not like your edits, and argued with you. What would you do?
How to Answer
The interviewer wants to learn more about how you work with authors and work through disagreements. Give a specific example, if possible. How you present your opinion to a writer is often more important than whatever is going on in the manuscript. We're all humans, and we all bring different experiences to the table. No one wants to be treated as if their time and skills aren't valuable. If you want the final product to be the best it can be, a healthy working relationship between writer and editor is a must.
Written by Sue Oberliesen on November 11th, 2021
Answer Example
"I've learned through my past experiences that a good editor should avoid changing an author's voice or writing style. The editor should ask questions of the author regarding unclear issues in the writing and offer suggestions on how to clarify for reader understanding. If an author does not like my suggested edits, I've found that it's best to open up the discussion, explain my point of view, and be respectful and straightforward. I'll offer suggestions and rewrite the sentence or paragraph so the author can see my points more clearly, but I typically let the author make the final call."
Written by Sue Oberliesen on November 11th, 2021