Tell me about a time you provided honest feedback to a coworker.
Giving honest feedback is an art form, and the interviewer would like to know you are capable of doing so. The goal of your response is to show the interviewer that you understand what honest feedback sounds like and how it's best delivered.
"When providing feedback, I like to use the 3x3 method, which I learned from my first management position. With this method, I offer three strengths and three potential areas for development. (Situation & Task) For instance, while working as a Team Leader with Company XYZ, I had a team member who was often late to work or would call in sick. (Action) I let her know that she was well-liked by her coworkers. I told her that our clients complimented her customer service skills and that I appreciated her willingness to help new hires. Then, I proceeded to let her know that her team felt disappointed and hurt and lost trust in her whenever she would call in sick, leave early, or show up late to her shift. Together we worked on a 30-day attendance plan. (Result) As a result, her reliability improved. Although her attendance was not perfect, it significantly improved."
"(Situation) A few years ago, I had a coworker who made me feel uncomfortable by rushing my tasks, looking over my shoulder, and criticizing the speed at which I worked. (Task) I was new to my career and felt hesitant to speak up. However, I knew that I was responsible for my job satisfaction. (Action) I approached them privately and reminded them that this was my first office job out of university and that I was still learning the role. I told them that their behavior made me uncomfortable and only worsened my productivity. (Result) As a result of my honest feedback, they apologized and committed to showing me their methods for time management. Because I was honest and forward, we were able to find a harmonious way to work together."
Avoid giving an answer that makes it seem like you are uncomfortable providing feedback to others. Instead, show the interviewer that you understand how to provide appropriate and helpful feedback. Research a variety of feedback frameworks and find a methodology that works for you.
The interviewer is asking you to be a storyteller. Form a brief story-based answer using the STAR method. STAR is an acronym for Situation, Task, Action, Result. Using this framework will ensure that you provide the interviewer with the right amount of information and detail to form a noteworthy response.
Remember to mention any training you have received on giving appropriate feedback. Perhaps you took a workshop or read a book on the topic. If you use a particular feedback methodology, be sure to share the details of your approach.
Community answers are written by other candidates practicing this set. Reading how others frame the same question is one of the fastest ways to sharpen your own.
Anonymous Answer
I sat with a peer after a performance discussion and asked if I could provide him feedback, he welcomed it. I gave him my comments and my reasoning for it. He understood where I was coming from. The next time we were in a discussion for a similar situation, he asked me afterward if he had been better.
Rachelle's Feedback
Most people will appreciate the honest feedback, but you mentioned a key component here, which is first asking permission to provide the feedback. You show strong professional courtesy. Nicely done!
