New Manager Mock Interview

Practice 40 New Manager interview questions covering leadership transition, team dynamics, and first-time management challenges.

Question 19 of 40

How do you approach providing constructive criticism or feedback to others?

Why the Interviewer Asks This Question
General
Community Answers

Rachelle Enns

Rachelle Enns is an interview coach and job search expert. She works with candidates to perform their best in employment, medical, and post-secondary admission interviews.

Giving constructive criticism and helpful feedback isn't as simple as it sounds. There is an art to providing feedback to others without making them feel defensive or put down. The interviewer would like to know that you are capable of this challenging task. When you provide constructive criticism, it's important that you:

- Provide specific details about the actions that need to be changed.
- Make the feedback actionable and set achievable goals towards change.
- Provide a clear timeline for this change to occur.
- Follow up regularly to ensure change is being made.

Discuss any formal training you have received or a book you have read on the topic. Perhaps you use a particular methodology to deliver feedback that generates positive results the majority of the time. If you have a specific story-based example of a time you provided honest feedback with a positive result, be sure to weave in the details of this real-life example.

Rachelle Enns

Rachelle Enns is an interview coach and job search expert. She works with candidates to perform their best in employment, medical, and post-secondary admission interviews.

"I have been learning about the 3x3 method for giving feedback. With this method, I offer three strengths and three potential areas for development. I recently applied this method with a co-worker who often arrived late or called in sick. I let her know that I enjoyed working alongside her. I told her that our clients often complimented her customer service skills. I also said I appreciated her willingness to help me when our workload increased. Then, I proceeded to let her know that I felt disappointed and let down whenever she would call in sick, leave early, or show up late to her shift. I told her how it impacted my work and explained that her actions often meant that I needed to work late to reach our goals. She apologized and told me that she would work on her attendance. So far, her reliability has significantly improved, and I am glad that I approached her using this method."

Interview Coach

Jaymie

A real coach, not AI. I read every answer myself and write back with personalized feedback.

Typically responds within 24 hours.

0 - Character Count

Anonymous Answer

I approach providing constructive criticism and feedback to others as if I was speaking with myself. That old adage, treat others as you would want to be treated. I consider how I would phrase the goals for improvement, using positive feedback, followed by areas for improvement to ensure that the conversation overall is empowering as opposed to correctional. Typically two positives followed by a needs improvement, but also asking how I could support them more to get them back on track, or to the place where they need to be in their position. I try and keep the conversation real and authentic, as I approach leadership and management as a supporting role most of the time, not a "boss" who "tells" employees what to do. I have always found people whether peers, coworkers, or students, if they are able to learn on their own, they perform better and with pride.

Jaymie's Feedback

Perfect! This is a great approach. Your response highlights your ability to communicate effectively, treat others with respect, and be a supportive manager.

Previous Question Next Question

40New Manager Interview Questions & Answers

Leadership

1.What kind of managers have you looked up to in the past?

Leadership

2.Talk about a manager that you did not connect with. How will you lead your team differently?

Competency

3.This position will be your first management role. Why should we give you this opportunity?

Teamwork

4.What type of people do you believe you can lead most effectively?

Discovery

5.How do you showcase your leadership abilities in your personal life?

Problem Solving

6.When you encounter a problem with another individual, how do you approach the situation?

Compatibility

7.What is the number one quality that will contribute to your success as our new manager?

Problem Solving

8.Managers should be strong problem solvers. Talk about a time when you solved an important issue in the workplace.

Leadership

9.In your current position, what efforts have you put into helping your co-workers to learn and grow?

Problem Solving

10.As a new manager, what do you believe will be your most significant challenge?

Management

11.Managers must command the attention of their team members. As a new manager, how do you plan to achieve this goal?

Job Satisfaction

12.Since this is your first management opportunity, how can we best support you to ensure your success?

Communication

13.How do you plan to set and communicate goals for your team members?

Teamwork

14.What would you do if a team member was not working efficiently?

Critical Thinking

15.As a new manager, what decision do you think will be the hardest for you to make?

Management

16.This is your first management role. Will you feel comfortable delegating to others?

Problem Solving

17.If a project was threatening to run over budget or over deadline, how would you handle the situation?

Leadership

18.Managing and leading others is a task that requires constant growth and learning. What resources do you use to learn about effective management approaches?

Communication

19.How do you approach providing constructive criticism or feedback to others?

Critical Thinking

20.If you were to have hiring authority in this management position, what would you look for in the candidates that you choose to hire?

Behavioral

21.Talk about a time you had to act like a leader.

Behavioral

22.Tell us about a time when you disagreed with your leader and convinced them to see things your way.

Compatibility

23.Why do you want to begin your management career with our company?

Competency

24.How has your education prepared you to be an effective manager?

Career Goals

25.Talk about one of your professional goals. What actions are you taking to achieve this goal?

Compatibility

26.How would your closest friend describe you?

Leadership

27.Tell me about a time when you had to lead by example.

Problem Solving

28.How would you present bad or disappointing news to your team members?

Accomplishment

29.What is your greatest work-related accomplishment to date?

Career Goals

30.What are your career aspirations beyond your first management position?

Adaptability

31.How do you go about earning the trust and support of a team you are being introduced to?

Leadership

32.How do you go about incentivizing your team in high-pressure situations?

Accomplishment

33.What does success look like to you at the end of the day?

Leadership

34.What leadership style do you relate to most?

Problem Solving

35.Tell me about your approach to taking a risk when you didn't have all of the information necessary to solve a problem.

Diversity

36.What's your approach to encouraging innovation in the workplace?

Leadership

37.Tell me about the last time you took the initiative to mentor someone on something.

Management

38.Talk about a time you helped motivate a struggling employee and improved their performance.

Communication

39.Talk about a time where you faced difficulty reaching a consensus in a time sensitive situation.

Problem Solving

New Manager Mock Interview

How do you approach providing constructive criticism or feedback to others?

40New Manager Interview Questions & Answers

1.What kind of managers have you looked up to in the past?

2.Talk about a manager that you did not connect with. How will you lead your team differently?

3.This position will be your first management role. Why should we give you this opportunity?

4.What type of people do you believe you can lead most effectively?

5.How do you showcase your leadership abilities in your personal life?

6.When you encounter a problem with another individual, how do you approach the situation?

7.What is the number one quality that will contribute to your success as our new manager?

8.Managers should be strong problem solvers. Talk about a time when you solved an important issue in the workplace.

9.In your current position, what efforts have you put into helping your co-workers to learn and grow?

10.As a new manager, what do you believe will be your most significant challenge?

11.Managers must command the attention of their team members. As a new manager, how do you plan to achieve this goal?

12.Since this is your first management opportunity, how can we best support you to ensure your success?

13.How do you plan to set and communicate goals for your team members?

14.What would you do if a team member was not working efficiently?

15.As a new manager, what decision do you think will be the hardest for you to make?

16.This is your first management role. Will you feel comfortable delegating to others?

17.If a project was threatening to run over budget or over deadline, how would you handle the situation?

18.Managing and leading others is a task that requires constant growth and learning. What resources do you use to learn about effective management approaches?

19.How do you approach providing constructive criticism or feedback to others?

20.If you were to have hiring authority in this management position, what would you look for in the candidates that you choose to hire?

21.Talk about a time you had to act like a leader.

22.Tell us about a time when you disagreed with your leader and convinced them to see things your way.

23.Why do you want to begin your management career with our company?

24.How has your education prepared you to be an effective manager?

25.Talk about one of your professional goals. What actions are you taking to achieve this goal?

26.How would your closest friend describe you?

27.Tell me about a time when you had to lead by example.

28.How would you present bad or disappointing news to your team members?

29.What is your greatest work-related accomplishment to date?

30.What are your career aspirations beyond your first management position?

31.How do you go about earning the trust and support of a team you are being introduced to?

32.How do you go about incentivizing your team in high-pressure situations?

33.What does success look like to you at the end of the day?

34.What leadership style do you relate to most?

35.Tell me about your approach to taking a risk when you didn't have all of the information necessary to solve a problem.

36.What's your approach to encouraging innovation in the workplace?

37.Tell me about the last time you took the initiative to mentor someone on something.

38.Talk about a time you helped motivate a struggling employee and improved their performance.

39.Talk about a time where you faced difficulty reaching a consensus in a time sensitive situation.

40.Tell me about the last time you didn't meet your goals when leading a team.