How do you respond to feedback and criticism? Describe a situation where your work was criticized. What was your immediate reaction to the situation?

Question

Nisha Yadav · Accepted Answer

"Last year, I received a low grade on a chemistry project. When I approached my professor about the low grade, he said, 'You can do better. I expected more from you.' I was taken aback at first, but once I had time to absorb what was said, I realized that he expected more from me because he had high expectations of what I was capable of doing. It was a compliment and a challenge rolled into one! I re-did the assignment with more passion the second time around. My grade improved significantly, and I thanked that professor for holding me to a higher standard."

Nisha Yadav · Answer

During your four years of dental school, your classwork and clinical rotations will be highly scrutinized. The faculty and mentors at this program won't hesitate to give you constructive criticism on your work. Your interviewers need to know that you can take this feedback constructively and productively.

Ryan Brunner · Answer

Not all feedback will be delivered in a friendly, easy-to-absorb manner as a dental student. Think of a time you received feedback or criticism that was a bit hurtful or surprising. Discuss how you reacted productively. Stress that you were able to take the criticism and learn from it moving forward. Talk about how you successfully implemented change.

Anonymous User · Answer

"I take feedback and criticism as a source of motivation and what others might see in me to improve. In particular, after my involvement incident. I was told my chances of attending a professional institution were slim to none. However, I took that criticism to push myself to work harder, perform well on the DAT, and improve my undergraduate GPA from that point on. Although, I always believe there is always room for improvement. I did the best I can, and I am here being interviewed at my top choice university. So the criticism I got was definitely helpful because It motivated me."

Anonymous User · Answer

"At the end of my Biology of Cancer course semester, our professor allowed the class to write their research proposal. Since I worked in the cancer research lab of the professor who assigned us the proposal, I did not hesitate to submit the research I was working on, for over a year, with my grad student mentor. To my surprise, I did not receive a grade only the following," Disappointed. You can do better." I kept rereading "disappointed," feeling more petrified and perplexed each time. After conversing with my grad student regarding the comment, I submitted a new proposal that introduced a new hypothesis that was deviant, novel, and uncertain. In the new proposal, I was exploring new areas I was unfamiliar with. Although I was very unsure of the new proposal, to my surprise, my professor gave me an A and told me that although my first proposal was perfect, the new one had encouraged me to think from new perspectives. He told me that in research, criticism can halt some and can encourage others to expand their boundaries and capabilities to achieve success. Although I fully agree, I believe that my professor's statement can be applied beyond the realm of research."

Anonymous User · Answer

"One of my personal strengths is my openness to feedback. I find an important distinction to make is that the criticism is critical rather than personal and the end goal is meant to improve my work rather than insult me. When I was in a 1st year university writing course I received a poor mark for a paper. This was a shock considering in high school I’d always received great marks.

I made an appointment with the TA to further inquire about what my paper was lacking. I took their advice to go to the writing center for help. And on my next paper I received a better grade"

Anonymous User · Answer

"When I first moved to the U.S. in 2018 and worked for a Thai restaurant as a waiter, I received a lot of online feedback saying that there was an immigrant waiter who could not understand their orders and worked very slowly. I was really sad at first but some of their constructive feedback motivated me to improve my service and communication skills with customers. In the third month of working there, I got used to the job, worked effectively in my team, and became the waiter in charge there. I love getting feedback and constructive criticism and I would highly appreciate people who give me those feedback."

Anonymous User · Answer

"I see feedback and criticism as a way to improve what I already have. My mom has always been a great critique for me, which helped me to understand the value of having someone to critique so that I can deliver the best performance that I can give. I think it helps me bring out my best potential."

How do you respond to feedback and criticism? Describe a situation where your work was criticized. What was your immediate reaction to the situation?

How to Answer: How do you respond to feedback and criticism? Describe a situation where your work was criticized. What was your immediate reaction to the situation?

Advice and answer examples written specifically for a Dental School job interview.

2. How do you respond to feedback and criticism? Describe a situation where your work was criticized. What was your immediate reaction to the situation?

Why the Interviewer Asks This Question

How to Answer

Answer Example

Anonymous Interview Answers with Professional Feedback