Practice 30 Metallurgical Engineering interview questions covering phase diagrams, failure analysis, and materials processing.
Question 28 of 30
How to Answer
Example Answer
Community Answers

Carilee Moran is a retired automotive engineer with 30 years of experience writing and editing technical reports.
This question explores how you would tackle a problem with extremely serious consequences for everyone involved with the product - not to mention those who might potentially be harmed by it. You will want to display that you have your priorities right. What the right priorities might be to the interviewer and the company he represents will be unknown to you, but if you answer the way an ethical engineer would, you can send a message of your own. If that's the kind of answer that the interviewer was looking for, then you've done well. And if the interviewer was looking for some kind of unethical thought process and didn't get it from you, thus disqualifying you from further consideration, so much the better for your conscience.

Carilee Moran is a retired automotive engineer with 30 years of experience writing and editing technical reports.
"This is a very serious question. I would like to work for a company where I do not have to concern myself with a potentially egotistical response from my supervisor upon being presented with evidence that a fault has cropped up with his masterpiece. The truth is that the fault may not have been foreseeable, so if he is a mature individual, worthy of being a supervisor in a technical role, his reaction to the problem would be to immediately call his manager to tell him about the problem, and to convey in no uncertain terms that production and sales must be suspended while we investigate.
If I don't think I can trust my boss with this information, then I really have no idea who I CAN trust at the company, as the culture may be corrupt in ways I had never even thought of. First, I would make very, very sure of my facts. Then I would think about whether I knew of any other supervisors that I felt could be trusted to do the right thing. If not, I would approach someone in the company's legal department, explain the situation, and let them advise me. If they did not support me with useful advice and help to make sure we stopped production and tackled the problem, I would submit my resignation, take on a personal lawyer, and let him advise me on next steps. I hope to God I am never faced with a scenario like this, and that if I am, that I am surrounded by ethical people who want to make it right. That has certainly been my experience of my engineering colleagues up until now."
Write Your Answer
0 - Character Count
Master technical questions on alloy selection, heat treatment, and microstructure analysis.
Get StartedJump to Question

Written by Carilee Moran
30 Questions & Answers • Metallurgical Engineering

By Carilee

By Carilee