MockQuestions

University of Minnesota Medical School Mock Interview

Question 4 of 45 for our University of Minnesota Medical School Mock Interview

University of Minnesota was updated by on June 13th, 2022. Learn more here.

Question 4 of 45

A woman comes into the ER after a car accident. She needs a blood transfusion but she states that her religion is against blood transfusions. What decision do you make?

"From what I understand, if the patient is of sound mind and they understand the risk they are taking by refusing medical assistance, I do not have the right to override her religious choice. Many factors could change this, such as an unconscious patient, someone under the influence of a narcotic, or perhaps if the person and I had a significant language barrier. In these situations, I should refer to my facilities' leaders and ethics community. This is a decision I would not feel comfortable making entirely on my own."

Next Question

How to Answer: A woman comes into the ER after a car accident. She needs a blood transfusion but she states that her religion is against blood transfusions. What decision do you make?

Advice and answer examples written specifically for an University of Minnesota Medical School interview.

  • 4. A woman comes into the ER after a car accident. She needs a blood transfusion but she states that her religion is against blood transfusions. What decision do you make?

      How to Answer

      The admissions interviewer at UMMS (University of Minnesota Medical School) would like to know if you are ready to face tough decisions while maintaining the integrity and code of ethics expected of you as a physician.

      You may not be able to answer this question completely correctly as there are many policies and legal requirements that you may not even know about yet. Answer to the best of your ability by displaying that you would make the soundest choice possible while maintaining the patient's integrity.

      Written by Rachelle Enns on June 13th, 2022

      Answer Example

      "From what I understand, if the patient is of sound mind and they understand the risk they are taking by refusing medical assistance, I do not have the right to override her religious choice. Many factors could change this, such as an unconscious patient, someone under the influence of a narcotic, or perhaps if the person and I had a significant language barrier. In these situations, I should refer to my facilities' leaders and ethics community. This is a decision I would not feel comfortable making entirely on my own."

      Written by Rachelle Enns on June 13th, 2022

      Anonymous Interview Answers with Professional Feedback

      Anonymous Answer

      "I think as a physician, it is important that I place the interest of my patients first. I have to respect their decision even if it may not be what I personally think is the best for the patient. However, I do believe it is my responsibility as her caretaker to be clear and inform her of the risks and possible outcomes depending on the choice she ultimately makes. Coming from a very traditional household myself, I understand that there are cultural aspects that are to be respected, for example, in the Hmong community, when there is a big decision to be made, such as a patient is to undergo surgery, it is usual that the elders of the clan make the final call instead of the immediate family. Therefore, I think as her physician, it is crucial to understand her position and beliefs."

      Rachelle's Feedback

      I love the unique insight that you bring to this hypothetical situation. This response shows that you are ready to do what's right as a physician. It's also clear that you are ready to act in a manner that shows empathy and understanding to others. Very well said, and I am thankful that I learned something new today, too :)

    • Next Question