How to Answer: What would you do if you witnessed a fellow resident acting unethically?
Advice and answer examples written specifically for a Residency job interview.
13. What would you do if you witnessed a fellow resident acting unethically?
Why the Interviewer Asks This Question
As you venture into a medical residency, you will be handling direct patient care on your own for the first time. With this comes immense responsibility. The interviewers want to know that, if faced with an ethical dilemma or a dilemma in reporting a breach of ethics, you will do the right thing as part of their residency program.
Written by Rachelle Enns
How to Answer
If you were trained in medical school on taking a specific course of action, now is the time to mention that. If not, you should create your own standard for ethics issues. Be sure to ask the interview panel if they have a system for reporting ethics issues at their institution. This will show that you have aninterest in being matched to their program.
Written by Ryan Brunner on February 12th, 2022
Answer Example
"If I see a fellow resident act unethically, I will refer to how I was trained to report ethical issues. First, I would ensure that I could identify the breach of ethics and determine the severity of the nature of the breach. If I witnessed a serious breach, I would identify the proper supervisor or faculty member who should be made aware of the breach and bring it to them as soon as possible. I have a clear set of moral values and will not turn a blind eye to any breach of ethics in the clinic or hospital from any staff member."
Written by Rachelle Enns
Internal Medicine Example
If I witnessed a fellow resident acting unethically, I would first ascertain the facts of the situation. If there was actually an ethical issue, I would act in accordance with the hospital's code of ethics, and report the issue to the correct staff member.
Written by Dr. Shani Saks on November 4th, 2022
Family Medicine Example
"If I witnessed another resident acting unethically I would try to talk to them about it. Oftentimes communicating with someone directly and asking why they are doing something a certain way is an important step in understanding what is actually happening. If they are truly acting unethically, I would then bring it to the attention of my senior resident."
Written by Dr. Griswold on November 5th, 2022
Radiology Example
"A colleague acting unethically while on service simply cannot be tolerated. I would first gather the facts of the matter and approach the resident regarding the case, especially if patient care was at stake. Next, it is necessary to report the behavior to our supervisor."
Written by Dr. Rodman on February 1st, 2023
Dermatology Example
"This would be a challenging situation for anyone. I would first approach my fellow resident, let them know what I had witnessed, and provide them the opportunity to inform residency leadership themselves to make amends. If my fellow resident refused to do so, I would let them know that, since I witnessed something unethical, it would be my duty to inform leadership, and I would let my program leadership know about what I had witnessed."
Written by Dr. Yumeen on December 19th, 2022
Emergency Medicine Example
"As physicians, we are held to an extremely high ethical standard and I believe it is our responsibility to address issues of unethical behavior within our profession. If I saw a fellow resident acting unethically, I would first confront that person directly and ask if they understood why what they were doing was unethical in order to give that person an opportunity to reflect and learn from the situation. However, I would have no hesitation in reporting any unethical conduct to a higher authority within the physician ranks to address any unethical behavior."
Written by Dr. Smith on December 31st, 2022
Anonymous Interview Answers with Professional Feedback
Anonymous Answer
I would also like to ask the interviewer how they (the program) would respond to such a situation."
Jaymie's Feedback
Anonymous Answer
Jaymie's Feedback