How to Answer: How would you handle providing constructive feedback to your manager?
20. How would you handle providing constructive feedback to your manager?
The Goal
Providing feedback to others in a constructive manner is a challenging skill to obtain, so the interviewer wants to know that you have worked on your constructive feedback skills. The goal of your response is to take the interviewer through your feedback delivery process, ensuring they see your approach as a good fit for their workplace culture.
Written by Rachelle Enns on March 16th, 2022
What to Avoid
Avoid telling the interviewer that you would never give constructive feedback to your manager. Yes, it is essential to respect your leaders. However, providing them with opportunities to improve is one way to show that you also care about their professional growth.
Written by Rachelle Enns on March 16th, 2022
Pro Tip
The interviewer wants to know how you would proceed with giving constructive feedback to your leaders. Because this question is positioned as, 'How would you...,' you can respond hypothetically. The Situation, Solution, Benefit formula is helpful in this instance.
Step 1) Situation: Express your understanding of the hypothetical situation.
Step 2) Solution: Outline the solution you would introduce in this hypothetical situation.
Step 3) Benefit: Highlight how your approach to delivering feedback will benefit the hiring company.
Written by Rachelle Enns on March 16th, 2022
How to Answer
Giving proper constructive feedback can be an art form in itself. Show the interviewer that you understand how to provide appropriate feedback, even if it's for the person to whom you report. Suppose you have encountered a situation like this in the past. In that case, you can use the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to provide a story-based example to support your initial Situation, Solution, Benefit response.
Written by Rachelle Enns on March 16th, 2022
Answer Example
"(Situation) It can be intimidating to give feedback to the person you report to; however, providing helpful feedback can ensure that my leaders grow and improve as well. (Solution) If I were to provide constructive feedback to my manager, I would first ensure an appropriate time and place. Ideally, this feedback would occur during a 1:1 meeting or a performance review. Next, I would keep the conversation focused on work versus any potential personality clash. I would never bring up any personal matters or habits that seemed nit-picky. My feedback would be solution-oriented and based on fact versus feeling. I'd also provide positive feedback so that my manager would not feel discouraged or overwhelmed. (Benefit) Regardless of seniority, everyone deserves to be told the truth; however, only in a kind and constructive manner. Should Company ABC hire me, you'll find that I am a thoughtful communicator who encourages sharing valuable information to my co-workers and leaders."
Written by Rachelle Enns on March 16th, 2022