Many attributes make a good surgeon. The American College of Surgeons describes critical factors that make a good surgeon as intelligence, conscientiousness, professionalism, courage, creativity, and perseverance. They also say that becoming a good surgeon is a lifelong process and that surgeons are trained, not born. The ACS also describes surgeons as individuals who appreciate working on a team, embracing responsibility and making a positive impact, and those who excel at problem-solving using critical thinking skills. The interviewer wants to hear your description of what makes an excellent surgeon to assess if you are a good fit for their team.