MockQuestions MockQuestions

Do you think it is possible to be a good team member, yet disagree with the leader?

1 of 25 Teamwork Interview Questions and Answers Written by Rachelle Enns

Updated on June 29th, 2018 | Rachelle is a job search expert, career coach, and headhunter
who helps everyone from students to fortune executives find success in their career.
How to Answer

The interviewer wants to know that you can be diplomatic in the workplace, even when you may not agree with your leader. Show the interviewer that it is possible for you to be a good team member, yet disagree with the leader from time to time. Explain that you believe everyone is entitled to their own professional opinion, yet capable of maintaining respect for each other at the same time. Show that even if you disagree with the final decision they make, you support the direction the team is heading.

Professional Answer Examples
Answer example

"I think that it is possible to be a great team member, even when disagreeing with the leader. It's all in how you maintain respect for each other despite the difference in opinion."

Answer example

"Yes, I think it is possible! What makes a great team member is not that they agree with everything but the level of respect and positive thought that goes into the person's communication style. It's okay to disagree; however, you have to communicate your thoughts professionally."

Answer example

"I have had team members disagree with the decisions that I have made as a manager, and it does not bother me unless they are disrespectful about the situation. I think it's great to face challenging thoughts in the workplace and I welcome varying trains of thought."

Answer example

"Yes, I do believe it is possible to be a good team member, yet disagree with the leader. I have disagreed with decisions my boss has made in the past, but generally, I keep my thoughts to myself, and I know they are the leader for a reason and likely have considered factors, beyond my understanding, for their choices."

Answer example

"I do wish to work with a leader with whom I agree most of the time. This agreeance doesn't have to be all of the time, but I do work best with leaders whom I understand."

Answer example

"It is possible to get along with any leader, no matter a difference of opinion, so long as everyone maintains a level of respect. This respect should go both ways as well. Everyone has a different work style, and differences will always be present."

Answer example

"Getting along with others is usually a choice that one makes. I can disagree with my leader but still know that they are making the decisions they feel are best for the good of the students, faculty, and school in general."

Attendance Clerk
Answer example

"I think that it is possible to be a great team member, even when disagreeing with the leader. It's all about how you maintain respect for each other despite the difference in opinion."

Written by:

Rachelle Enns
Rachelle Enns is a job search expert, executive headhunter, career catalyst, and interview coach. Utilized by top talent from Fortune companies like Microsoft, General Electric, and Nestle, she helps professionals position themselves in today's competitive digital marketplace. Rachelle founded Renovate My Resume and Executive Resume Solutions, two companies focused on helping job seekers get their edge back. She helps everyone from new graduates looking for their first placement, to CEO's who want more out of their career. Rachelle coaches students to executives on how to master the toughest interview questions and how to handle the most bizarre interview situations; all with confidence and poise. Rachelle trains other career coaches, recruiters, and resume writers, globally. A big part of her job is also spent coaching HR professionals on how to bring the human touch back into their interview and hiring process.
First written on: 02/02/2016
Last modified on: 06/29/2018

More Interview Questions

View user-submitted Answers

Do you think it is possible to be a good team member, yet disagree with the leader?
Yes its every possible to be a good team mmeber and still disagree, some times the best solutions come from disagreements.
I do. It is fine to disagree and challenge a decision professionally. However, the leader is the leader for a reason and should be respected.
Yes. Everyone should be able to add input.
No. It's not good: it should be solved after evaluation and discussion.
Yes I believe that time to time its okay to raise voice when there is a disagreement because that is how as a team can come up with a better solution.
Absolutely. There have been occasions when I have disagreed with my manager, but, when it comes down to it, the decision is up to the leader and then you adapt your outlook to best benefit the team.
I believe conflict a time for learning new things and solving problems. Regardless of agreeing or not I am a team player and will work towards the team's goal. But what is important in education she to keep in mind what is best for the studen. Ts. I also know there is a time and place to disagrree.
Everyone has different perspectives. In that situation I would try to find a way we can merge our ideas for the betterment of the company.
I think it's okay to disagree with the leader but it depends how you express it to him/her. As long as you're not expressing it in an argumentive tone.
Disagree yes, but also understanding that the team leader has more knowledge & training.
Yes. If you feel that there is something morally incorrect or if the decision goes against your own beliefs.
Yes, I believe it is possible. I believe it's possible because you can disagree with the leader and have others have that same mind set, and it's possible to be able to say that you disagree with a leader in a professional way, and find a way to get the leader and everyone else to agree to whatever the issue is.
Yes. Your boss is your boss for a reason. They are better trained to know the best way to proceed with situations.
You can have your opinion but team leaders no the job much better and what they say goes.
Yes. You don't have to agree with the decision but you do have to get it done.
Yes. With that being said, your delivery and how you project yourself is important when doing so. It's not about whose right or wrong but what will be the best outcome for the situation.
Yes. It is possible the leader not to lead good in some instances.
Yes because nobody's perfect. If you're working as a team you're working towards the same goal together.
Yes providing you are not disagreeing all the time and are politely explaining your ideas but also giving positive feedback to the team leaders ideas.
Yes, as everyone should be able to offer thoughts and ways of implementing work to achieve overall objective.
Yes I believe it's possible to be a good team member, but not always have to agree with the leader . The team is the main focus to the community too. We have the leader who helps us set goals, and reach them. The team mates helps us futher on in life.
Yes as long as it does not interfere with the goal at hand not everyone sees things exactly the same all the time.
No, having a personal opinion that speaks otherwise can gradually cloud your judgement.
Yes as long as you do it with respect.
I think you have to all be on the same page you are not always going to agree but you should try and see things from there point of view.
Yes I don't agree with the leaders all the time but I always make sure I approach them in a non argumentative way.
Yes I think it is possible because we all have different perspectives.
I would not disagree with the team leader because he or she knows what their in charge for to settle all the work better.
Yes the work still needs to be completed.
Yes, that makes for more productive out come.
Yes, the stance I would play pertains to my background and will prove invaluable to the team in due time. It is not about knocking the leader of their perch, but to gain their trust and respect to have opportunities to voice your opinion and be able to back it up with substantial information to have the leader consider my opinion. Having diversity in a team proves a jewel in its own time.
Consider every one work with me a good player because this is the the extension of the effectiveness as amanager.
Yes, promotes originality and ideas.
Yes. May have an alternative way of achieving goals, may have had past experience that would help achieve goal.
Yes, everyone has different ideas.
No we need to work group no matter who is the leader or co-worker so that to encourage time management other things basically for job need.
I believe it is most important to show clear and concise leadership and listen to all your team members, ultimately it is about demonstrating ways of working that are logical while respecting other points of view.
Yes because every members opinion matters even though disagreements may occur. You might learn something from the other person.
Yes, Sometimes you may not agree with the leader.
Yes, but you mustn't disrespect your leader.
Yes, but first we have to listen to our leader idea and at the same time give our opinion. That is what team works are.
Definitely. Disagreement sharpens the contradictions and an amicable resolution is arrived at and then the job of the team continues.
Yes I do. Not everyone agrees with each other but I don't think disagreeing with someone will make you a bad team member.
Yes it is possible depending on the thought process and experience. Good Team member defines tuning and flexibility in nature to carry a task where as it may vary the idea or thinking processs of the leader.
My opinion may differ from the leader, however it is important to still work as a team.
Yes, I hope to be good team member and play important roles.
Yes it is. Definition of a good team member does not limit to taking directions from the leader. When the leader errs, it is also the responsibility of the members to remind the leader of the correct procedures to prevent compromising the quality of work delivered.
Yes, It possible to be good team member is disaggrement is constructive.
Yes if disaggrement is constructive and able to convince to the team leader.
Yes, that makes for more productive out come.
Get More Interview Practice
Pick your topic
Ask the Interviewer
Questions you may consider asking the interviewer, about ...
We all have some behaviors that are typical of us and whi...
Common Interview Questions
There are some questions that employers ask at almost eve...
If you are interviewing for any type of leadership role; ...
Most interviews start with a telephone interview. Hiring ...
Everyone struggles with tough interview questions. Learn ...
View more topics